Buying a Printer: Ink Tanks vs Cartridges and the True Cost of Ink

The printer itself is the cheap part. The ink is where the money goes — over three years, ink can cost several times the price of the machine. Printers with refillable ink tanks cost more up front and far less to feed. Printers that take cartridges cost little up front and a lot to feed. Which one wins depends on how much you print.

The two kinds of ink

Cartridge printers are the ones most people know. The ink comes in small plastic cartridges you snap in and replace. The printer itself often sells for $60 to $100 — sometimes it seems nearly free. The catch: a set of cartridges runs $40 to $80, and a set may last only a few hundred pages. The maker earns its money on the refills, a little like selling the razor cheap and the blades dear.

Tank printers (sold under names like EcoTank and MegaTank) hold their ink in clear tanks you refill from bottles. The printer costs more — about $200 to $300 — but a bottle of ink costs about $15 to $20 and prints thousands of pages. Many tank printers even come with enough ink in the box for a year or two of ordinary printing.

The three-year math, honestly

Say you print about 100 pages a month — letters, forms, boarding passes, a recipe now and then. That's 3,600 pages in three years.

Now say you print lightly — maybe 15 pages a month, a form here and a return label there.

The verdict: heavy printers save real money with a tank. Light printers come out about even — and for them, the cartridge printer's low shelf price is a fair deal. There's a second catch for very light use, below.

The drying-out problem (matters if you print rarely)

Ink is liquid, and liquid dries. If a printer sits unused for weeks — any ink printer, cartridge or tank — the ink can clog the print head (the part that sprays ink onto the page), and prints come out streaky or missing colors. If you print only a few times a year, print one small page every couple of weeks to keep things flowing, or consider whether the library's printer covers your rare needs. People who print photos or documents every week rarely meet this problem.

The third kind: laser printers (the light printer’s best friend)

There is a third kind worth knowing about, and for some households it beats both ink kinds. A laser printer prints with toner — a dry powder — instead of liquid ink. Powder cannot dry out or clog, so a laser printer can sit untouched for months and print perfectly the day you need it. If you print only a few pages a year — a form, a return label, a boarding pass — a simple black-and-white laser (about $100 to $150) is the standard answer: no ink drying up, no cleaning cycles, and a toner cartridge that can last for years at that pace. The trade-offs: home lasers print black-and-white only (color lasers exist but cost much more), and they are not for photos. Print your photos at the drugstore and let the laser handle the paper.

What else to ask about

What a decent one runs

Cartridge models: about $60 to $120. Tank models: about $200 to $300. Simple black-and-white laser models: about $100 to $150. All of them go on sale often, and last year's model is usually the same machine for less.

If you'd like help weighing two printers — or working out which kind fits how your household actually prints — call Sean at (813) 770-6082.

Words in this lesson

Straight 2 Work Tech, LLC — patient, plain-words tech help.
(813) 770-6082