Smart TV or a Simple TV With a Streaming Stick?

Every TV sold today wants to be 'smart,' but you have two ways to get Netflix, Roku-style apps, and free streaming channels: built into the TV, or in a small stick that plugs into the back. Neither is wrong. This lesson explains what 'smart' really buys you, and the one situation where a stick rescues a TV you already own.

What 'smart' means, without the sales talk

A smart TV is a TV with a small computer inside that runs apps — Netflix, YouTube, Hulu, free services like Pluto TV and Tubi — over your home Wi-Fi. A streaming stick or box (Roku, Fire TV Stick, Google TV Streamer, and Apple TV are the big names) is that same small computer in a thumb-sized package that plugs into a port on the back of any TV from the last fifteen years or so. The apps, the picture, and the shows are the same either way. What differs is the remote in your hand, how fast the menus feel, and what happens in five years.

The built-in systems have names too, and they are not all equal: Samsung TVs run Tizen, LG runs webOS, and many other brands (Sony, TCL, Hisense) run Google TV or Roku TV inside. If the TV already on your wall has one of those systems and still feels quick, it may not need a stick at all. Two boxes deserve a special mention: the Apple TV box is the natural pick for an all-iPhone household — no ads in the menus, and it can show your iPhone’s screen on the TV in one tap — while the Google TV Streamer is Google’s current box, and the one that fits an Android household best.

Decide in four questions

  1. Is your current TV's picture still good? If yes, a stick gives it a whole new brain for a small fraction of a new TV's cost. This is the single best value move in television.
  2. Do you want one remote or is two acceptable? A smart TV does everything with its own remote. A stick adds a second small remote (though most sticks can also control the TV's power and volume once set up).
  3. How do the menus feel? A TV's built-in system is frozen at the speed it shipped with, and TVs are rarely updated after a few years. A stick that feels slow in five years can be replaced by itself, cheaply, while the TV stays.
  4. Who will use it most? For a guest room or a second TV, a stick on the existing set is plenty. For your main chair, where you watch every night, the all-in-one smart TV is the simpler daily life.

One honest warning about bargain smart TVs

The very cheapest smart TVs sometimes pay for their low price by being slow and by showing ads in the menus. If a deal seems too good, the picture panel is fine more often than the software is. Buying a plain good TV and adding a name-brand stick is a respectable way around that — many technicians do exactly this at home.

Good to know

'Smart' has nothing to do with picture quality. A ten-year-old TV with a great panel and a new stick will show a sharper, prettier picture than a brand-new bargain smart TV. Buy the picture first; the smarts can always ride in a stick. And keep the stick's receipt: it is the cheapest upgrade in the house, and the first thing to replace when streaming starts to feel sluggish.

Words in this lesson

Straight 2 Work Tech, LLC — patient, plain-words tech help.
(813) 770-6082