Before You Give: Check a Charity in Five Minutes
Most charities are honest. The fakes survive by sounding almost identical to them — a name that is off by one word, and a voice in a hurry. You do not need to become a detective. Three free lookups, done in about five minutes, separate a real charity from a costume. Do the checking before you give, every time the request came from someone who contacted you.
The five-minute check
- Write down the exact name the caller, letter, or email used — every word of it. Scam charities live in the small differences: a real-sounding name that is not quite the famous one. Ask the caller to spell it, and to tell you their web address.
- Ask the IRS. Go to irs.gov and search for Tax Exempt Organization Search. Type in the name. If the charity is real, and your gift counts as tax-deductible, it is listed there. No listing? That is a hard stop — do not give.
- Ask the independent rater. Charity Navigator (charitynavigator.org) is a free service, run by neither the charities nor the government, that rates charities on their finances and honesty. A charity with a decent rating has had its books examined by someone with no reason to flatter it.
- Ask Florida. Charities that ask for money in Florida must register with the state — the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FDACS). Its Check-A-Charity tool, at floridaconsumerhelp.com, shows whether the charity is registered, and how much of its money reaches the actual cause compared with office costs and fundraising. No computer handy? Call 1-800-HELP-FLA (435-7352) and ask them to look it up for you.
- Give your way, not their way. Passed the checks? Give through the charity's own website — typed by you, never the link you were sent — or by a check mailed to the address you found yourself. Never through the caller who rushed you, and never by gift card, wire transfer, or cash.
Pressure tells that end the call
Real charities are happy to be checked. These moves mean the opposite — any one of them is reason enough to hang up:
- "You have to give today." A disaster, a deadline, a matching gift that expires within the hour — the rush exists so the five-minute check never happens.
- "Thank you for your pledge." You never made one. The line is a trick to make paying feel like finishing something you started.
- Payment by gift card, wire transfer, or cash only. Real charities take checks and cards. Unusual payment is the scam's fingerprint, because it cannot be taken back.
- A name that is almost a famous one. One word changed, one word added. That is exactly why step one of the check is writing the name down.
- They will not send anything in writing — or the local-looking number on the caller ID belongs to a group based three states away. Caller ID can be faked. Treat it as a costume, not a fact.
The hang-up rule
Here is the whole lesson in one sentence: a real charity never minds you hanging up and calling back on a number you found yourself. Write the name down, hang up politely, run the check at your own speed, and give later if it passes. If they do mind — if the voice turns pushy, hurt, or urgent — you already have your answer, and it cost you nothing.
One more thing the check tells you: many phone callers are not charity workers at all, but paid fundraisers — companies hired to make the calls, who keep part of what you give. The Florida lookup shows how much of a charity's money reaches the cause itself. When that share is small, your gift does more good given directly on the charity's own website.
Words in this lesson
- Tax-exempt: the IRS has recognized the group as a real charity, so it pays no tax on the money it takes in — and gifts to it can count as tax-deductible for the giver. The IRS search confirms both.
- Paid fundraiser (solicitor): a company a charity hires to ask for donations by phone or mail. It is legal — but part of your gift pays them, which is why the Florida numbers matter.
- FDACS: the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services — the state office that registers charities asking Floridians for money, and runs Check-A-Charity.