Passwords & accounts
This one trips up a lot of folks, and I wish the phone stores warned people about it. Those codes went to your old phone — your new phone doesn't know it's you yet.
If you still have the old phone, the fastest fix is to move the codes over yourself: in Google Authenticator, go to the menu > Transfer accounts > Export accounts on the old phone, then Import accounts on the new one.
The other fix is a set of backup codes: one-time codes you print out and keep somewhere safe, like your password book. For Google accounts, get them at your Google Account > Security & sign-in > 2-Step Verification > Backup codes. Do this before you ever lose or replace a phone.
If you're already locked out, call me — there are recovery steps, but they're slow on purpose, because Google has to make sure it's really you.