505.My Mac keeps asking for a keychain password. What do I do?
A little box keeps popping up on your Mac asking for the password for the “login” keychain — when you open Mail, when Safari starts, sometimes the moment you log in. Here is what is going on, in plain words: your Mac keeps its saved passwords in a locked drawer called a keychain, and that drawer has its own password. Normally the drawer’s password is the same as the password you use to sign in to the Mac, so it unlocks quietly and you never see this box. The box appears when the two passwords have drifted apart — most often because the Mac’s sign-in password was changed or reset at some point (a forgotten-password reset is the classic cause) while the drawer kept the old one. The pop-up itself is not a virus and not a scam when it is the Mac’s own plain system box — but never type your password into a box that arrived inside a web page or an email; those are fakes, and you can close the page instead.
- First try: your OLD Mac password. The next time the box appears, type the password you used to sign in to this Mac before it was last changed — an older one you may not have used in months. If the drawer opens and the boxes stop, you have found it: the drawer was still locked to the old word. That is the whole fix for most people, and nothing else below is needed.
- If the old password works, marry the two passwords again. Open the Keychain Access app (press Command + Space, type Keychain Access, press Return). In its Settings (older Macs: Preferences) or by right-clicking login in the left-hand list and choosing Change Password for Keychain “login”, set the keychain password to your current Mac sign-in password. From then on the drawer unlocks silently at sign-in, as it should. (Menu words drift a little between Mac versions; the address that stays put is Keychain Access → the login keychain → change its password.)
- No old password works? The honest reset. In Keychain Access, open Settings and choose Reset My Default Keychains, then restart the Mac. This hands you a fresh, empty login drawer whose password matches your sign-in. The honest cost, stated plainly: passwords the Mac had saved only in that old drawer — some Wi-Fi and website passwords — are gone with it and will need typing once more as you meet them. Nothing else on the Mac is touched: no files, no photos, no email itself. If that trade sounds steep, stop here and let Sean do it with you, so the few passwords worth saving are written down first.
- One look-alike worth knowing: a box asking for a keychain password right after you sign in, every time, naming “login,” is the drift above. A box that names an app you just opened, once, is often that app asking permission to use a password it already saved — choosing Always Allow with your keychain password is safe there. Boxes that appear while you browse the web, with warnings and phone numbers, are never this — close the page and do not call anyone.
The one-minute version: type your OLD Mac sign-in password into the box. If it opens, set the login keychain’s password to your current one inside Keychain Access and the pop-ups end. If no password opens it, Reset My Default Keychains in that same app ends them for good — at the honest price of re-typing the passwords that drawer alone remembered.